Building the Campaign Trail: How Direct Mail can Shape Voter Habits by Jill Corcoran

June 29, 2022 • Posted by DM20

Jill Corcoran, President of Who’s Mailing What!, wrote this article about what trends are apparent from political mail campaigns, five key insights about election mail, and how you can use them to improve your mail. Enjoy!

The first votes in some 2022 elections have already been cast, but if you’re involved in a political campaign, it’s not too late to consider using direct mail. Whether it’s your first political rodeo or your 30th, your
challenge remains the same: to get the attention of potential voters, inform them about your candidate, make the case for their support, and, finally, get them to cast their vote.

That’s not an easy task. The average American sees hundreds of promotional emails, pop-ups, Facebook and Google ads, TV commercials, videos, texts, signs, and other communications every day.

Direct mail can help you cut through all that clutter.

Recently, we conducted research into what trends are apparent from election and political mail campaigns and developed five key insights about political and election mail — and how you can use them to improve your mail and drive citizens to participate in our democracy.

1) Target Voters with Segmentation

Because data is the king of direct mail and a crucial factor in its success, you must use it correctly. There’s certainly a time for generic election messaging, such as when you’re introducing, or re-introducing, your candidate.

But as a campaign progresses, you can also segment your political database and send mail to groups of voters based on an incredible variety and combination of data points. Working with a credible data supplier, zero in on specific audiences whose values and profiles better align with yours. Design mail pieces that speak to these attributes by highlighting your experience, issue positions, and specific proposals.

Some of the examples we came across demonstrate how campaigns — as well as official election bodies — reach out to different demographics, as shown in this voting information effort mailed by Sacramento County.

2) Emotional Motivators

Separate neuroscience studies by Temple University and True Impact reveal that messages found on physical printed material, such as direct mail, involve more emotional processing and create
better recall and motivation to act than digital ones. Now imagine the power of print paired with visual and verbal cues that tap the seven main emotional drivers and you have a powerful combination that drives actions:

  • Guilt
  • Fear
  • Anger
  • Salvation
  • Exclusivity
  • Flattery
  • Greed

Then there’s another motivator that works so well in election and political mail: patriotism. This non-partisan election information mail piece, from Fulton County (Georgia) Department of Registration and Elections, breaks out the big type (“YOUR VOICE”) in white against a background of blue and red stripes.

Remember — after deciding on an emotional touchpoint, you can then align facts and figures to support your candidate’s message on issues.

3) Copy

Don’t be subtle. You and your candidate can’t afford it! Just tell your voters what you want them to do next, and keep it short. Some examples:

  • “Go to for my full plan on saving endangered species.”
  • “Register by .”
  • “Vote on ”
  • “Return your ballot by ”

Also, show them how! Provide clear instructions, like your campaign website or phone number for more information, or a map showing the physical location of their polling place. We discovered many campaign mailers in our database that took this helpful approach. Official election agencies, such as Arizona Vote, mailed easy-to-follow directions for residents receiving their ballots by mail.

4) Design

Your mail should make the best possible impression about your candidate, once you’ve gotten your audience’s attention in the first place. This means including these elements:

  • Easy-to-read fonts
  • Crisp, high-resolution photos
  • No cheap or dated-looking material
  • No spelling, grammatical, or factual errors

Also, use white space and short headlines — when you’re not showcasing content — to let the voter’s eyes and mind focus on the candidate and the message. And make sure no one misses your call-to-action: when (and how) they can vote in the election.

One of the most eye-catching examples we found in our research is this campaign mailer by Citizens for Lake Metroparks based in Painesville, OH. Notice how keywords and phrases are highlighted as well as the large type emphasizing the ballot measure number.

5) Inspire Action Across Channels

Political campaign mail in 2022 might look on the surface a lot like mail from 10, 20, or 30 years ago. But it’s not.

The internet means that political mail can be more powerful than ever before if you use it as part of an integrated, ongoing, omnichannel experience for your candidate’s supporters and potential voters. Reinforcing a consistent message across all channels builds trust in the eyes of your intended voters.
Think of how you can keep voters engaged with your campaign and other supporters using:

  • Smart speakers/VACTA call-to-action
  • Informed Delivery campaigns
  • Retargeting website visitors with a postcard
  • QR code call-out to drive website visits
  • Social media listings

Our research showed that many election administration bodies, party organizations, non-profit groups, and individual candidates have been using many of these digital channels to keep voters engaged after they receive their mail.

Santa Clara County (California) mailed a small brochure with helpful voter information. It directs residents to the county’s election sites (via QR code) and social sites.

The bottom line here is that direct mail is a living channel that combines the best of modern-day marketing and print technologies to help your campaign reach today’s voters.

May the Best Candidate Win

Your direct mail can do a lot of heavy lifting in identifying, educating, and energizing core supporters and independent voters. Even as marketing strategy evolves from “spray and pray” to data driven, your mail must ultimately answer a big question all voters, like consumers, have: “What’s in it for me?”

Jill Corcoran has been building teams to serve marketers for the past twenty years. Employee and client happiness have always been her “North Star.” Jill runs the world’s most complete resource of direct mail campaigns: Who’s Mailing What! Visit for more information, connect with Jill on LinkedIn, or contact her at 212.660.9880 or [email protected]